← Blog

Sometimes the Research Dead-Ends

November 17, 2026·By Brodie Wells

This week we ran funder research on twenty nonprofits. Thirteen of them came back with nothing we would hand anyone.

That is not a bug report. It is the most honest number we have, and it is the subject of this post. This is the second in a series built from 84 sources on what makes grant seeking painful. The first post argued that the real problem is fit, not discovery. This one says the part a grant research company is supposed to leave out: sometimes the research is done well and the answer is still no.

What a dead end actually looks like

Here is one from this week, with the name left off because they did nothing wrong.

A city genealogical society, decades old, with a real membership and a real program. We ran a peer search: which foundations have funded organizations like this one, according to their filed tax returns? The answer came back in seconds.

  • 4 foundations, 9 grants, $2,054 in total, across five filing years. The average grant was $228.
  • One of the four was a shopping-donation program that Amazon shut down in 2023. It will never give again.
  • One was a large corporate foundation that wrote three small checks, the shape of an employee match, not a grant program.
  • The other two both told the IRS they give only to preselected organizations.

There is no prospect list in that. What it shows is a group funded by its members, its dues and its events, which is a perfectly healthy way to be funded. Foundation research is simply the wrong tool for it, and the most useful thing a tool can do is say so in a minute instead of letting someone spend a month finding out.

The other twelve were dead ends for different reasons

Not every dead end has the same shape, and the shapes matter, because some are final and some are not.

  • No foundation money in the field at all. A rowing club, a stormwater quality association, a school association. Their peers are funded by members, fees and sponsors, not foundations.
  • Nothing came back. Three searches returned no results under two different spellings of the name. That can mean nobody funds organizations like these. It can also mean the funders wrote the name differently on their returns. We cannot tell those apart from the data, and we will not pretend to.
  • One very large funder and nothing else. A single global foundation behind every peer is a fact about that foundation, not a pattern a small organization can follow.
  • Real funders, nothing new. One organization had a genuine foundation base behind it and its peers, but nothing we could verify as a new prospect it does not already know. The research worked. It just had nothing new to say.

What the peer trail can tell you, and what it cannot

A filed 990 is a record of what a foundation actually did, which is why we start there instead of from a mission statement. It can answer questions like these:

  • Has this funder given to an organization your size, in your area, recently, and more than once?
  • Is it growing or shrinking its giving?
  • Does it tell the IRS it only funds organizations it already picked?

It cannot answer the questions that decide most grants:

  • Whether the funder is tapped out this cycle.
  • Whether the board's attention has moved to something else.
  • Whether the program officer already has a candidate in mind.
  • Whether the one grant to an organization like yours was a relationship that will never repeat.

Erin Tatum of Nonprofit Nomad, a consultant with no software to sell, put it better than we can: "Good grant prospect research is mostly the art of saying 'no.'" On geography she adds, "Geography isn't just about checking the state on an eligibility list. It's about understanding where a funder has actually chosen to invest." A foundation's own giving history shows where it chose. It does not show where it will choose next year.

So what is the tool for?

Making the no faster and better informed. Not making it stop being a judgment call.

A clean research process that ends in "foundations are not your channel" is a finished job. It frees the hours for the funding sources that are: members, events, individual donors, a government contract. A research process that ends in a 118-name list of "aligned matches" you have to disprove one by one is not finished at all. It has handed you the work and called it a result.

So when a search comes back thin, read it as an answer, not a failure. Look at who the peers are. If they are funded the way you are, by people rather than foundations, the dead end is telling you something true about your field. If a different set of peers tells a different story, follow that trail instead. And if you have done both and the answer is still no, it is allowed to be no.

Next week: the other thing we are not supposed to say. When the research does work, it makes your workload worse.